Gordon Stokes Transport  

Other Transport Assessment aspects

Transport Home Photography Home  

Last updated - March 2015

Pages in this series

1 - Transport Assessment Introduction

2 - Trip generation

3 - Routes taken by traffic

4 - Pass by, diverted and other trips

5 - Other aspects

6 - Transport in Environmental Statements

Other aspects of transport assessments - Summary

This page contains comments on various apsects of reviewing Transport Assessments not found on other pages. It currently includes

  • Traffic that "planning permission already exists for"
  • Predicting how traffic increases will impact on junctions
  • Travel Plans
  • When is traffic congestion 'severe'?

Calculating what traffic already exists

All proposed developments will be replacing something else, and that something else may have traffic associated with it. For green fields and long derelict land, this will be zero or neglibible so can be ignored. But for many it's important to know how much traffic the current development generates, since the new development will be replacing that. In addition for some aspects of a TA it may be relevant that some land use has been used in the past, but not at the moment (see the next section on calculating what traffic did exist but not any more).

Calculating what traffic did exist, but not any more (extant)

For the purposes of calculating how much 'compensation' developers should pay to Local Authorities to mitigate the traffic impact of a development (Section 106 payments), the relevant figures for traffic that 'currently' exists includes traffic for which planning consent exists. Thus if an empty office block is being replaced by something else, then it's important to know how much traffic one would expect the offices to produce, were they full.

The usual way to do this is to do 'Trics' traffic generation runs for the current development and use those, but some issues need to be borne in mind, namely whether the trip rate assumptions are right, and how long it's been unused with respect to how much should be paid, and more importantly whether it can really be argued that that traffic is relevant to increased traffic flows:

  • As with forecasting of future trips it is important to study the trip rates carefully - see "Trip Generation" page. In this case the TA may try to show somewhat higher trip rates for the extant land uses (while for the new land uses lower rates may be used). They are likely to use the same Trics runs, but if a large office is being replaced by a development with a very small office they may use rather high trip rates, so the 'extra traffic' seems less. Similarly (or counterwise) if a development involves, say replacement of mixed land use, inlcuding offices, with solely offices, the TA may use lower than expected trip rates, so that while less is forecast for the old smaller offices, less is also shown for the larger replacement.
  • Calculation of pass-by, and linked trips may be different for the existing and new land uses. This shuold probably be questioned.
  • How long a site has been unused for can be relevant. No one would suggest that a building empty for 100 years should be counted as having 'planning permission' for full use. Most guidance is silent on this issue, but Transport for London guidance states "in cases where the substantial parts of an existing site have lain dormant for a significant period then this could lead to an over-estimation of existing impact and in turn an underestimation of net impact of any proposed development. Therefore where it is clear that an existing site has been dormant or substantially vacant (i.e. over 25%) for over a year then it is reasonable for the purposes of sensitivity testing to require the TA to adjust the existing scenario accordingly. This will then lead to a more realistic assessment of net impact."
  • While the payments to Local Authorities should be based on non-existant land use, the impacts on congestion and safety will depend on the increase from 'today'. If a road is close to capacity, and the extra traffic would lead to gridlock it is unrealistic to argue that amenity will not be lost because the traffic would have been that much greater had the land use been used to its full capacity, especially if local traffic has had a chance to grow since the land use was vacated.

https://www.tfl.gov.uk/info-for/urban-planning-and-construction/transport-assessment-guidance

(The counter to phantom traffic - ease of changing landuses)

If a TA argues that there is permission for vacant areas of the site, then it should also admit that landuses can be changed. If permission is granted for "A1" retail then it can be any A1 land use. An application for furniture stores (which have low trip rates) could be changed to food stores (which have very much higher trip rates). A1 (retail) can also be changed to A2 (financial and professional) and there are other changes possible, but the main one to think about is in the wide ranges (A1) retail. Funnily enough I've never seen a TA that uses that argument!

But similarly housing can be applied for as a low generating class (such as rented flats), but then change to owner occupier which has higher rates. Or from private houses converted into flats.
Link to Planning Portal in new window - www.planningportal.gov.uk/permission/commonprojects/changeofuse/

Predicting how traffic increases will impact on junctions

This is really techie stuff. More may be added on this in the future, but in the meantime it's worth reading "Transport Assessment Health Warning" by Barbara Chard (Traffic Engineering and Control, 2008) for likely errors in delay forecasting at junctions and the likely associated hidden costs to Local Authorities for not thoroughly checking these modelling aspects.

Travel Plans

Travel Plans are statements of intent which usually aim to show how people's travel behaviour will be changed so that fewer users of a site will arrive by car than the forecast suggests. They are not restricted to being a part of a TA, and have been written for facilities such as hospitals and some large offices since the early to mid 1990s. Besides as adjuncts to a TA they are generally written either where an organisation wants to use its land more efficiently, or when government suggests that they should be done (e.g. for hospitals about 15 years ago).

For TAs the aim will usually be to show reduced expected travel by car, or to show that a car park will not be used to capacity. Guidance states that all TAs for large developments should incorporate a Travel Plan. On the face of it Travel Plans are pretty straightforward and understandable documents but many contain unrealistic statements which may make it seem that traffic will be far less than is likely.

Elements used in Travel Plans

Travel Plans can include a number of proposed measures, such as:

  • Charging for parking on site, or not permitting parking by certain classes of user (such as employees). These are 'stick' measures that tend to be effective, but also unpopular.
  • Information on using public transport. Where public transport is well provided, sometimes it only needs a bit of information and encouragement to get some people to use it. This is a 'carrot' measure that doesn't cause any pain but may not actually produce very much behaviour change on its own. To provide information packs on public transport provision is unlikely to bring about very much behaviour change at all.
  • Encouraging cycling, by providing secure covered cycling parking, and showers (usually at workplaces). The effectiveness of this will depend on how developed local cycling culture is, as well as the location and type of development.
  • Improving local infrastructure such as bus waiting areas, footpaths and cycle lanes, usually as part of a Section 106 agreement with a local authority

It's generally reckoned that for a Travel Plan to be effective it needs to include both carrot and stick measures and to be continually monitored. Many offered with TAs tend to be somewhat optimistic, such as suggesting that information on public transport will do the trick. But some organisations treat them seriously, knowing that they can actually save money by reducing the need for car parking and so using their land more intensively. And "Active Travel" (walking and cycling, or even bus use as it involves a walk) is known to have major health benefits to society and the health service.

At what level does traffic congestion become "severe"?

The National Planning Policy Framework suggests that a development should be allowed (on traffic grounds) if the impacts are not severe, but then makes no attempt to guide readers as what 'severe' means. Even if a TA is 'tested' by appeal then what was deemed severe (or not) by a planning inspector would probably not provide a precedent for many other proposed developments.

Some points are worth making.

  • What is severe in a quiet rural area is different to what is severe in inner London
  • Some organisations define 'congestion' as when traffic speeds drop below the speed limit for that roads. (By such a calculation one firm said that the A34 through Oxfordshire saw congestion on over 9,000 occasions in a year - that's about 30 times a day - mind you; it is one of the busiest dual carriageways in the country)
  • If traffic levels are close to 'saturation' then it takes a very small amount of extra traffic to tip it over into congestion (meaning long queues and delays at junctions)
  • Some TAs will say that because of congestion in the area they expect 'peak spreading' to occur. That is when people stagger their journey times to avoid the peaks. If that really is the case then the TA writers are really arguing that congestion IS severe and their development will only make it even worse. Otherwise they are arguing that there is no such thing as severe congestion (which is maybe what they are trying to argue) by implying that if it's bad people will spread their journeys. Having and eating cake springs to mind!
  • Some TAs talk of a development not producing traffic levels that would be "severe, as defined by the NPPF" or similar wording. This is meaningless. What they are saying is that since there is no agreed definition, no development could produce 'severe' congestion.



The next page is a brief look at transport in Environmental Impact Statements

Back to Transport Index

Gordon Stokes, 2015